Homes for sale in Shirley, NY
Figures for Shirley, NY, week ending September 15, 2026.
Paige
watching Shirley · 113 homes for sale
Paige
We saw 12 homes come on the market in the last 7 days here in Shirley. It keeps things moving, even as the total homes for sale in Shirley right now sits at 113. If you want to look at specific places today, 254 Auborn Avenue is a 3 bedrooms residential home asking $399,999 that was listed 1 day ago. We also have 158 William Floyd Parkway, a 3 bedrooms residential home listed 127 days ago that is now asking $480,000. Looking at the broader picture, the median days on market for what is listed is 22 days. Sellers are definitely making adjustments to keep interest alive, with 7 asking prices reduced in the last 7 days at a median reduction of 6.7%. Meanwhile, the median asking price of everything listed is $550,000, with 104 listed under $800,000. It shows us how quickly fresh inventory moves compared to homes that have been standing for a while.
What kind of home are you looking for in Shirley?