Homes for sale in Bay Shore, NY
Figures for Bay Shore, NY, week ending September 15, 2026.
Paige
watching Bay Shore · 101 homes for sale
Paige
Sellers just made the biggest move of the week at 893 Gardiner Drive, bringing that residential home down from $899,000 to $829,000. It is a 5 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms residential option with 2578 square feet that has been listed for 28 days. If you want something smaller, there is 99 Newbrook Lane #99 in Newbrook Gardens, a 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom residential property offering 810 square feet for $319,999 after 21 days on the market. Looking across the whole city, properties are moving relatively fast with median days on market for what is listed sitting at 18 days. New inventory is coming on slowly with just 6 new properties in the last 7 days, while 3 asking prices were reduced with a median reduction of 4.6%. That shows sellers are willing to adjust when their property sits past the average timeframe, even as overall options remain focused under $800,000 where 72 of the active options sit.
What kind of home are you looking for in Bay Shore?