THE AGENCYpowered by

Homes for sale in Bay Shore, NY

Figures for Bay Shore, NY, week ending October 25, 2026. Last week's read — this week's is still being written.

Paige

watching Bay Shore · 98 homes for sale

Paige

11 homes came on the market in the last 7 days here in Bay Shore. I can walk you through 991 Gardiner Drive in West Bay Shore, a 3 bedroom residential 17 days on market that asking $699,000 after being reduced from $779,000. There is also 44 Pinebrook Place #44 in Newbrook, a 1 bedroom residential asking $299,000 that has been on the market for 22 days and was reduced from $305,000. If you need residential income, 1306 Potter Boulevard has 3 bedrooms, an asking price of $625,000, and has been listed for 24 days. Right now we have 98 homes for sale with a median days on market of 19 days. While 11 new properties arrived, 9 listings saw asking prices reduced in the last 7 days, with a median reduction of 2.4 percent. That shows sellers are actively adjusting their expectations to meet where active buyers are today. What kind of home are you looking for in Bay Shore?

991 Gardiner Drive

For SaleOneKey® MLS

991 Gardiner Drive, Bay Shore

3 bd · 2 ba · House · 17 DOM

1062234, Century 21 AA Realty, Antoinette L. Petruzzello

44 Pinebrook Place Unit 44

For SaleOneKey® MLS

44 Pinebrook Place Unit 44, Bay Shore

1 bd · 1 ba · Condo · 22 DOM

1060824, Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC, Jack Ramsay

1058 Bay Shore Avenue

For SaleOneKey® MLS

1058 Bay Shore Avenue, Bay Shore

3 bd · 1 ba · House · 7 DOM

1064941, Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty, Samantha Lordi

1596 Forks Road

For SaleOneKey® MLS

1596 Forks Road, Bay Shore

4 bd · 3 ba · House · 8 DOM

1065960, Legacy Estate Realty, Tehzibakhtar Saiyed

For SaleOneKey® MLSOpen Sat 1-3 PM

35 Joyces Way, Bay Shore

2 bd · 3 ba · Townhouse · 9 DOM

1065692, Michael J Watts & Assoc Inc, Michael J. Watts

247 Delaware Avenue

For SaleOneKey® MLS

247 Delaware Avenue, Bay Shore

6 bd · 3 ba · House · 9 DOM

1066009, NY Homes Realty Group LLC, Qasir Ahmad GRI CBR

1316 Brooklyn Boulevard

For SaleOneKey® MLS

1316 Brooklyn Boulevard, Bay Shore

2 bd · 2 ba · House · 10 DOM

1064716, Jones Hollow Realty Group Inc, Justin Roemer

For SaleOneKey® MLS

40 Muncey Road, Bay Shore

5 bd · 4 ba · House · 10 DOM

1065288, Keller Williams Legendary, Marty Vandenburg

1009 Joselson Avenue

For SaleOneKey® MLS

1009 Joselson Avenue, Bay Shore

2 bd · 1.5 ba · House · 10 DOM

1065402, Master Estates, Robert Newman

243 Vermont Avenue

For SaleOneKey® MLS

243 Vermont Avenue, Bay Shore

4 bd · 3 ba · House · 11 DOM

1056531, Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC, Tammy J. Ramsay

124 Ithaca Street

For SaleOneKey® MLS

124 Ithaca Street, Bay Shore

4 bd · 2 ba · House · 11 DOM

1064788, Signature Premier Properties, Tammy Gatto

11 Oakmont Lane

For SaleOneKey® MLS

11 Oakmont Lane, Bay Shore

3 bd · 2 ba · House · 11 DOM

1065652, Signature Premier Properties, Deborah F. Berkman

94 Smith Avenue

For SaleOneKey® MLS

94 Smith Avenue, Bay Shore

3 bd · 2 ba · House · 11 DOM

1065005, Uncommon R E, Abraham Pena

1056 Bay Shore Avenue

For SaleOneKey® MLS

1056 Bay Shore Avenue, Bay Shore

3 bd · 1 ba · House · 15 DOM

1063670, Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty, Dawn Sofio

1660 Gardiner Drive

For SaleOneKey® MLSOpen Sun 12-2 PM

1660 Gardiner Drive, Bay Shore

5 bd · 3 ba · House · 16 DOM

1063729, Nova Real Estate NY Corp, Michelle A. Juarez Garcia Prieto

1073 Oakneck Road

For SaleOneKey® MLS

1073 Oakneck Road, Bay Shore

3 bd · 3 ba · House · 17 DOM

1062312, Ed Ryan Real Estate Group, Edmond P. Ryan

For SaleOneKey® MLS

84 Oak Walk, Bay Shore

3 bd · 1 ba · House · 17 DOM

1062487, Nicholas Jay Newman, Nicholas Newman

30 Torrey Pine Lane

For SaleOneKey® MLS

30 Torrey Pine Lane, Bay Shore

2 bd · 2.5 ba · Townhouse · 17 DOM

1059661, Century 21 AA Realty, Sandra Mathis GRI CBR

116 Clinton Avenue

For SaleOneKey® MLS

116 Clinton Avenue, Bay Shore

4 bd · 2 ba · House · 17 DOM

1062728, Opendoor Brokerage LLC, Verria Hairston

1619 Brightshore Boulevard

For SaleOneKey® MLS

1619 Brightshore Boulevard, Bay Shore

3 bd · 1 ba · House · 17 DOM

1025583, Exit Realty Connections, Rosalee Demchak

For SaleOneKey® MLS

35 Circle Lane, Bay Shore

3 bd · 1 ba · House · 18 DOM

1062734, Herrick Real Estate LLC, Jose P. Nazario

1761 Manatuck Boulevard

For SaleOneKey® MLS

1761 Manatuck Boulevard, Bay Shore

4 bd · 2 ba · House · 18 DOM

1062298, Real Broker NY LLC, Shedettah Richards

1801 Stein Drive

For SaleOneKey® MLS

1801 Stein Drive, Bay Shore

4 bd · 1 ba · House · 18 DOM

1062130, Vantage Realty Partners, Mark Gaeta

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 10/30/2026, 6:11 PM EDT. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.

OneKey MLS Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID.

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use. It may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed by MLS GRID.

Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website.

Any use or search of this data other than by a consumer looking to purchase real estate is prohibited.

Tap a home and I'll open it here — we can keep talking about it.

More in Bay Shore

Nearby in Long Island & New York

Also

Talk to a local agent

Paige is AI in beta and can make mistakes. Conversations are stored and may be reviewed. Verify important details. Terms · Privacy