Homes for sale in Middle Island under $800K, NY
Figures for Middle Island, NY, week ending September 15, 2026.
Paige
Under $800K · Middle Island
Paige
52 homes of the 59 for sale in Middle Island are asking under $800K. The median asking price across everything for sale in Middle Island is $499,900, and what is listed has been on the market a median of 26 days.
What are you looking for in Middle Island?Paige's full read on Middle Island this week