Homes for sale in Middle Island, NY
Figures for Middle Island, NY, week ending September 15, 2026.
Paige
watching Middle Island · 59 homes for sale
Paige
The biggest price drop we saw over the last 7 days was on 58 Bailey Court #58, a residential home that dropped from $205,000 to $189,900. I can take you through that 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom home in Hidden Meadows, which has been listed 69 days ago. There is also 619 Spring Lake Drive in Birchwood, a 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms residential home asking $599,900 that came on 20 days ago. Right now, median days on market for what is listed sits at 26 days. With only 2 homes coming on the market in the last 7 days out of 59 homes for sale, inventory is moving slowly while sellers hold close to their initial numbers, showing just 1 asking price reduction across the board with a median reduction of 7.4 percent. It gives us a clear look at how patient sellers are being locally right now.
Are you looking to buy or sell a home in Middle Island?