Homes for sale in West Islip, NY
Figures for West Islip, NY, week ending September 15, 2026.
Paige
watching West Islip · 35 homes for sale
Paige
The most noticeable shift in West Islip this week was at 466 W 4th Street, where the asking price on that residential home came down from $699,000 to $669,000. If you are looking right now, I can take you to 616 Pat Drive, a 4 bedroom residential home asking $799,000 that came on 5 days ago. There is also 308 McCall Avenue, a 3 bedroom residential home asking $649,999 that has been listed for 19 days. Right now there are 35 homes for sale across the city, with 6 coming on in the last 7 days and only 1 price reduction across the board. The overall median days on market sits at 19, showing that inventory is continuing to turn over relatively quickly as new options arrive.
What kind of home are you hoping to find in West Islip?