Homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY
Figures for Shelter Island, NY, week ending September 15, 2026.
Paige
watching Shelter Island · 23 homes for sale
Paige
Only 2 homes came on the market in the last 7 days here on Shelter Island. It keeps the fresh options tight, but we have a couple of interesting entry points right now. You could look at 11 Jaspa Road, a 2 bedrooms residential home listed 4 days ago asking $1,350,000. If you need something larger, 169 N Ferry Road is a 4 bedrooms residential property that has been listed for 36 days, asking $4,250,000. Overall, with 23 total homes for sale and a median days on market of 71, things are moving at a measured pace, while the median asking price across everything listed currently sits at $2,800,000.
What kind of home are you hoping to find on Shelter Island?