Homes for sale in Middletown, NY
Figures for Middletown, NY, week ending September 15, 2026.
Paige
watching Middletown · 225 homes for sale
Paige
If you want to jump right in, 473 Ingrassia Road is a 4 bedrooms residential home asking $699,900, listed 19 days ago and reduced from $759,900. There is also 13 Benton Avenue, a residential income property listed 94 days ago that just had its price cut from $450,000 to $345,000. For a smaller footprint, 412 4th Avenue is a 2 bedrooms residential option listed 74 days ago, now asking $178,500 after a drop from $189,000. Looking at the wider picture, 16 asking prices were reduced in the last 7 days with a median reduction of 4.7%. With a median days on market for what is listed sitting at 26, properties that are priced to move are still finding traction quickly, while others are adjusting to meet where local buyers are taking action.
Are you looking to buy or sell a property in Middletown right now?