Homes for sale in Garden City, NY
Figures for Garden City, NY, week ending September 15, 2026.
Paige
watching Garden City · 36 homes for sale
Paige
The biggest move in Garden City this week was at 50 Commander Avenue, where the price dropped from $1,149,000 to $1,049,000. It is a noticeable shift for anyone keeping an eye on local residential properties. Right now, there are two fresh options to look at. The single family residence at 32 Cambridge Avenue has 3 bedrooms, covers 1496 square feet, and is asking $1,099,000 after 6 days on the market. If you are looking for something smaller, 101 2nd Street #B11 is a 1 bedroom residential unit with 794 square feet, listed 6 days ago for $439,000. Looking across the 36 homes for sale, inventory remains tight with only 3 new listings coming on in the last 7 days. However, sellers are showing flexibility, with 4 asking prices reduced by a median reduction of 6.6%. With a median days on market of 24 for all active listings, properties are moving relatively quickly, though buyers still have moments to negotiate.
Are you looking for a single family home or a smaller space?