Homes for sale in Fire Island Pines, NY
Figures for Fire Island Pines, NY, week ending September 15, 2026.
Paige
watching Fire Island Pines · 28 homes for sale
Paige
The most noticeable shift in Fire Island Pines this week was at 317 Sky Walk, a residential property that saw its asking price drop from $2,150,000 to $2,075,000. It is the main price movement we have seen across the island over the last 7 days. If you want to look at what is available right now, 418 Ocean Walk in Low 400's Section is a 3 bedroom residential home asking $3,500,000 that was listed 14 days ago. On the other end of the size spectrum, C-133 Harbor Walk #133 in Fire island pines is a 1 bedroom residential option asking $495,000, which has been on the market for 97 days. Looking at the broader picture, zero homes came on the market in the last 7 days, leaving total inventory at 28 homes. With a median days on market of 15 for what is listed and only 1 price reduction across the entire market this week, sellers are mostly holding firm on their initial positions rather than adjusting to lure in fresh interest.
What kind of home are you looking for in Fire Island Pines?