Homes for sale in Amityville, NY
Figures for Amityville, NY, week ending September 15, 2026.
Paige
watching Amityville · 57 homes for sale
Paige
The most noticeable shift in Amityville this week was at 58 Harbor Road N, where the price dropped from $495,000 to $420,000. It is a clear move in a market where 5 homes reduced their asking prices over the last 7 days with a median reduction of 6.8 percent. If you want to walk through some of what is available right now, 16 Robbins Avenue in Amityville is a 3 bedroom residential listed 11 days ago at $789,000. Over at 56 Washington Avenue in Amityville, there is a 2 bedroom residential asking $599,000 that has been listed 12 days. For something larger, 280 S Bayview Avenue offers a 6 bedroom residential income property listed 31 days ago for $899,999. Looking across the board, 7 homes came on the market in the last 7 days, bringing the total to 57 homes for sale in Amityville right now. With a median days on market of 24 for listed homes and a median asking price of $739,000, sellers are adjusting their positions quickly while fresh options continue to arrive.
Are you looking to buy or sell a home in Amityville?