Homes for sale in Old Brookville, NY
Figures for Old Brookville, NY, week ending September 15, 2026.
Paige
watching Old Brookville · 20 homes for sale
Paige
The biggest shift we saw this week was at 3 Valentine Farm Court, where the price dropped from $6,999,000 to $5,999,999. If you want to take a look around the area, I can show you 5 Woodfield Lane, a 5 bedroom residential home asking $2,995,000 that came on 14 days ago. There is also 33 Chicken Valley Road, a 6 bedroom residential property listed 40 days ago at $5,250,000. Right now we have 20 homes for sale in Old Brookville, with 2 new properties arriving in the last 7 days and a median days on market of 32 for current inventory. With only 1 price reduction this week, sellers are largely holding their ground while listings take a month or more to find their footing.
Are you looking to buy a home in Old Brookville soon?