Homes for sale in Amenia, NY
Figures for Amenia, NY, week ending September 15, 2026.
Paige
watching Amenia · 20 homes for sale
Paige
The biggest shift we saw locally this week was at 5 Lake Amenia Road, where the asking price dropped from $399,000 to $319,900. If you are looking in that price range, there are two homes nearby worth talking about. The first is 90 Lake Amenia Road, a 3 bedroom residential home asking $315,000 that was listed 13 days ago. The second is 309 Amenia Union Road, a 4 bedroom residential home asking $549,000 that has been listed for 19 days. Taking in the broader picture, 0 homes came on the market in the last 7 days, leaving us with 20 total homes for sale in Amenia right now. With listed homes sitting for a median of 86 days on market, the inventory we have is taking some time to move. Only 1 property had its asking price reduced in the last 7 days, making that 19.8% median reduction an unusual move for the week.
Are you looking for a home in Amenia right now?